DHS Privacy Suggestions on Agency Drone Programs

2016-01-12

As technology continues to blur the lines between privacy and security, the Homeland Security Department has several suggestions to help agencies consider civil rights and liberties issues when setting up their respective unmanned aircraft system programs.

The DHS Unmanned Aircraft Systems Privacy, Civil Rights and Civil Liberties Working Group, which department leaders formed about three years ago, released 15 best practices for agencies as they establish their own unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) or drones.

Co-chairs of the working group acknowledged that all suggestions might not apply to every agency. But DHS — specifically CBP — can draw on 10 years of experience from using unmanned aircraft to protect U.S. borders, they wrote.

“The DHS Working Group neither proposes nor intends that this document regulate any other government entity,” the co-chairs wrote in a joint statement. “Our goal, rather, is simply to share the best practices we have identified as helping to sustain privacy, civil rights and civil liberties throughout the lifecycle of an unmanned aircraft systems program.”

The group includes DHS Officer for Civil Rights and Civil Liberties Megan Mack, DHS Chief Privacy Officer Karen Neuman and Customs and Border Protection Deputy Assistant Commissioner Edward Young.

Many of the group’s recommendations serve as reminders to agencies that as they begin to establish UAS programs, they keep privacy, civil liberties and rights experts involved throughout the entire implementation process — from the procurement to audit and oversight stages.

Agencies should, for example, regularly keep track and submit reports to their legal, privacy, civil rights and civil liberties experts on all of their UAS activities and the complaints they receive.

Other suggestions center around the issue of information sharing and security.

Before setting up a UAS program, the group suggests some agencies conduct a Privacy Threshold Analysis to determine whether their programs will conduct personally identifiable information (PII).

Agencies should also set up security safeguards to prevent data loss or unauthorized access to PII.

“Security measures should be layered to avoid reliance on any single security measure,” the working group said. “Employ several measures that functionally overlap to create redundancy in the security of data and the overall program.”

But the guidelines lack specifics on how long agencies can store information about individuals, which Neema Singh Guliani, legislative counsel at the American Civil Liberties Union, said is a problem.

The working group, for example, suggests agencies establish an approved records retention schedule that would systematically get rid of the information that is no longer useful or legal to keep.

“Ensure retention periods are compatible with the type of data retained and needs of the unmanned aircraft program,” the group suggested. “Data collected that does not pertain to an authorized purpose should not be retained beyond 180 days.”

But Singh Guliani said agencies could do a lot with that information in 180 days. If one agency uses a drone to collect information for a specific, authorized purpose and holds that data for 90 days, it could give another organization that same information, she said.

“Right now, if you have information for an authorized purpose — whatever that means — and throughout the course of that you want to use if for another purpose, there’s nothing that says you can’t do that,” Singh Guliani said.

The 15 best practices are:

1.Consult legal counsel, privacy and civil rights and liberties experts at each step in the formation process.

2.Publicly state the purpose for setting up an unmanned aircraft system program.

3.Publicly document any changes to the program’s purpose.

4.Put a senior official, preferably one in an agency’s privacy and civil liberties office, in charge of overseeing the program.

5.Consult privacy and civil liberties experts throughout the implementation process.

6.Conduct an analysis of possible privacy and civil liberties concerns before establishing a program.

7.Limit the data and information that unmanned aircraft systems collect and keep, and comply with records retention policies.

8.Respect constitutional activities.

9.Set up a redress program that can receive, investigate and address privacy, civil liberties and rights complaints.

10.Establish audits and other accountability procedures.

11.Design the UAS with the proper security controls to ensure that the right data stays in the proper place.

12.Include legal, privacy and civil rights considerations in the procurement process.

13.Maintain a transparent and open relationship with the public about the UAS and its implementation.

14.Train personnel on privacy and civil liberties issues that may come up when operating an unmanned aircraft system.

15.Develop a system for handling UAS service requests.

Though the recommendations are intended for federal, state and local agencies, as well as government partners and grantees, the private sector might also find them useful, the co-chairs wrote.

2015-12-08

Japan’s Clue launches DroneCloud, data management platform for businesses using drones

Tokyo-based Clue announced in November the launch of a data management service for drones called DroneCloud. The service will offer a platform to manage drone data, such as tracking who operates which drone, managing projects and team members operating drones, as well as managing and sharing drone flight data.

2015-11-30

Minnesota DoT Testing Drones for Bridge Inspections

“We do underneath rope access inspections,” said Barritt Lovelace, a regional manager for Collins Engineers Inc., an agency headquartered in Chicago with offices throughout the country. “Basically, we rock-climb bridges. It’s a lot of fun.” In Duluth recently, Lovelace stood with a host of others below the Blatnik Bridge to participate in a demonstration of the Minnesota Department of Transportation’s ongoing study of using drones for bridge inspection purposes.

2015-11-23

Over 2,100 Commercial End Users, Vendors at First Annual Drone World Expo

The first ever Drone World Expo had an extremely successful launch last week at the San Jose Convention Center. The exhibit hall floor featured 75 exhibiting companies and the event attracted 2,120 commercial drone professionals. The exhibitors responded enthusiastically about their experience at the new trade show with many already planning on renewing booth space for the 2016 Show which will take place November 15-16 back at the San Jose Convention Center.

2015-11-11

Drone Standards Tough To Reach For Young Pilots

Megan Halek could be the best unmanned aircraft pilot coming out of the University of North Dakota’s highly regarded aviation program this year: She’s aced a training program and has enough air experience to fly private jets worldwide.

2015-11-04

Drone World Expo – Exclusive Board Member Interviews

To find out what inspires their interest in UAS and attracts the Advisory Board Members to support Drone World Expo, we scheduled a series of exclusive interviews. Our eleventh interviewee is Gretchen West, Senior Advisor of Innovation and Technology at Hogan Lovells.

2015-10-26

US DoT Seeks Public Comments on UAS Registration

In a surprise move, DOT just published a document,Clarification of the Applicability of Aircraft Registration Requirements for UAS and Request for Information Regarding Electronic Registration for UAS, to the Federal Register. DOT is soliciting recommendations on all aspects of the UAS registration process, including which UAS should be exempt from the registration requirement.

2015-10-20

UK Military Aviation Authority to Update Unmanned Operations Guidelines

The UK’s Military Aviation Authority is preparing the release of an updated version of its regulations on unmanned air vehicles, which will draw on feedback from a first document that was released last January.

2015-10-09

Drones are providing film and TV viewers a new perspective on the action

Adazed and bloodied student who had just been mugged stumbled down a darkened alleyway in a slum. He lifted his shirt, revealing a gaping wound, before collapsing on the ground as curious onlookers gathered around.

2015-10-04

Air National Guard wants to Fly MQ-9 Reaper from Syracuse’s Hancock Airport

The Air National Guard wants to fly remotely piloted aircrafts out of Hancock Field at the Syracuse International Airport. The change would save time and money, as the National Guard has to send its aircrafts to fly from Fort Drum because of airspace restrictions.

2015-09-29

NASA Grant Supports Wildfire Research

Two Northwest Nazarene University assistant professors have been awarded a NASA grant to support their research on wildfire monitoring and assessment technology.

Assistant professor of computer science Dale Hamilton and associate professor of computer science Barry Myers weer awarded a NASA EPSCoR (experimental program to stimulate competitive research) Undergraduate Research Grant

Back to the list

Reports

2021-05-05
Development of the world market of UAV during COVID-19 pandemic

The drone market has grown steadily and continuously over the past several years. The technology is here to stay and is becoming more prevalent across numerous industries. But 2020 was a unique year due to Covid-19. Overall, respondents even felt that the changes in business models triggered by the lockdowns would actually have a positive impact on the drone industry in the long run.